• Mixtapes
    • Metal Mixtapes
    • Minor Key Mixtapes
    • Christmas Mixtapes
  • Mini Movie Reviews
    • Full List (A – Z)
    • Recent Reviews
  • Board Game Reviews
    • Recent Reviews
    • Children’s Game Reviews
    • Expansion Reviews
    • Full List (A-Z)
  • Reader Mail
  • About
  • Contact
  • Home
  • Mixtapes
    • Metal Mixtapes
    • Minor Key Mixtapes
    • Christmas Mixtapes
  • Mini Movie Reviews
    • Recent Reviews
    • Full List (A – Z)
  • Board Game Reviews
    • Recent Reviews
    • Children’s Game Reviews
    • Expansion Reviews
    • Full List (A-Z)
  • Reader Mail
  • About
  • Contact

Minor Key Monday 56: Mumford and Sons – I Gave You All

August 18, 2014

I always have to stop myself when I say I like “all kinds of music”.  Because, honestly, that just isn’t true, there is really only one kind of music I like.  No, not [just] Black Metal, I’m talking about music in a minor key.  I mean, I’m a pretty happy guy, but there is something about sad, sad songs that just does it for me.  I don’t dislike Vivaldi’s “Spring” and “Fall”, but I far prefer “Summer” and “Winter” (guess which seasons he writes in a minor key).  “Satisfaction” is a fine song, but I’d rather listen to “Paint it Black” any day…you get the idea.  Basically, it don’t mean a thing if it ain’t got that sting [of soul crushing sorrow and sadness]

This month on Minor Key Monday I talk one of those rare banjo-centered songs that I actually quite like:

https://www.isleyunruh.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/Mumford-and-Sons-I-Gave-You-All.mp3

I’ve really never been able to listen to much bluegrass–I don’t hate it, it’s just usually not the most epic and sorrowful style of music.  Folk, however, is right down my alley (as long as it is, of course, in a minor key and/or made by gay fascists).  Thus, despite their subtle stench of bluegrass, I’ve had a grudging respect for Mumford & Sons ever since I was first exposed to their music with that silly video where Jason Batemen and company play banjos and cry and stuff.  While I liked that song (“Hopeless Wanderer”), I was recently introduced to today’s song, “I Gave You All,” and finally decided Mumford & Sons were ready to join the “big leagues” of Minor Key Monday (you know, alongside such musical luminaries as Ace of Base).

Based on my brief exposure to their music, Mumford & Sons seem to love big epic Godspeed You Black Emperor style buildups.  And, like Godspeed You Black Emperor, too often the epic buildups are just a bit too post-rock/hipster/hopeful sounding for my tastes.  Today’s song, however, largely stays on the right side of that line.  There’s not much hope to be found in the straightforward sorrowful sequence of chords that slowly build to a fairly epic, banjo-driven climax.  Even the lyrics, despite sounding slightly too thesaurus-indulgent for my tastes, are pretty good (though I’m still trying to figure out that “If only I had an enemy bigger than my apathy I could have won” line).

I’ve tried listening to some more of their catalog, and while I’ve found other songs I appreciated as well, I have a feeling this one is probably destined to be my favorite.  It’s not as testicle-grindingly soul crushing as my normal jams, but I’d still happily listen to something like “I Gave You All” any day.

Finally, a quick word on banjos.  Sure, thanks to Deliverance they have a pretty redneck reputation, and sure, they are a staple of bluegrass, but I’m starting to wonder if I haven’t been a secret banjo fan all along.  Because, I have to admit, when the banjo comes in on today’s song it really sounds pretty great.  And the best song on Madonna’s last album also prominently featured a banjo.  At the very least, I suppose I am probably banjo-curious.  I’ll have to see if there is any banjo black metal out there that isn’t also post-rock/hipster/hopeful sounding bullshit.  Yes, I’m looking at you Panopticon.

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)

Related

Share

Minor Key Music  / Non-Metal Music

4 Comments


Willie
August 19, 2014 at 10:06 am
Reply

Solo banjo 78s are clearly the kvltest of all early american music. Step you game up.



Isley Unruh
August 19, 2014 at 12:25 pm
Reply

Hehe, and hey, you know your banjos, what else should I check out that doesn’t sound like it was played by a bunch of retirees that look like Santa Claus?



Willie
August 19, 2014 at 2:44 pm
Reply

Dock Boggs, John Hammond, and Clarence Ashley have some examples of the haunting recordings that I’m talking about in the 20’s and 30’s. Ola Belle Reed and Roscoe Holcomb weren’t recorded until the 60’s and 70’s but share a lot of that sound.

Technically though you will be bound to not really like them as they are mostly without an identifiable key. They come pretty close to being modal but are often simple enough as to not even fit definitively into one mode or another. Sometimes they have multiple “inflections” for the same note in the scale.



Brian
August 20, 2014 at 6:54 pm
Reply

I like the cut of your jib, Willie.

You’ve heard that Taake banjo song, right Isley?



Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • Recent Comments

    • Shane on Top Ten Best Classic Black Metal Logos
    • BBK on Five More Signs That the Underground Metal Band You Are Listening to Might be Racist
    • Anonymous on Boys will be Boys: Double Standards in McLintock! and The Awful Truth.
    • isley.unruh on Brilliant Board Games 1 – Krosmaster: Arena
    • Boosh on Brilliant Board Games 1 – Krosmaster: Arena
  • Recent Posts

    • Wrestling Fan Sign Hot Takes
    • RTfISP 11: Operation Moses
    • Notes from the Library
    • Top five 2023 New Year’s Resolutions for www.isleyunruh.com
    • Painting in Miniature 6: Blood Bowl
  • Categories

    • Art (5)
    • Books (12)
      • Only the Good Parts (6)
    • Comics (6)
    • Film (249)
      • Best Movies of the Decade (2)
      • Best Movies of the Year (5)
      • Cinema Scripture School (4)
      • James Bond Picture Books (2)
      • Mini Movie Reviews (98)
      • My Favorite Movies (78)
      • Year in Reviews (6)
    • Food and Cooking (9)
    • Games (52)
      • Brilliant Board Games (2)
      • Descent D&D (7)
      • Mini Board Game Reviews (12)
      • Painting in Miniature (6)
      • RE-Zork (10)
    • Holidays (21)
      • April Fool's (8)
      • Halloween (2)
    • Internet (30)
      • Memes I Missed (21)
      • The Art of Trolling (4)
    • Lists (49)
    • Mailbag Monday (86)
    • Math and Science (3)
    • Me (60)
      • Rousing Tales from Isley's Spirited Past (12)
    • Metal Music (121)
      • Album Artwork for the Ages (3)
      • Battle Vests of the KVLT & TR00 (3)
      • Best Metal of the Year (6)
      • Extreme Metal Radio Edits (2)
      • Mid-month Metal Masterpiece (74)
      • Racism in Metal (6)
    • Myth and Fantasy (8)
      • Archetypical (4)
    • Nerd Open Letters (20)
    • Non-Metal Music (102)
      • Minor Key Music (90)
    • Other (2)
    • Philosophy (3)
    • Sports and Fitness (8)
    • Spotlight Posts (60)
    • Tales from Center Valley High (19)
      • Goth Blog (6)
      • Jock Blog (7)
      • Snob Blog (6)
    • Tolkien (97)
      • The Lost Chapters (6)
      • Travels in Middle-earth (76)
    • TV (5)
    • War (7)
  • Archives

  • Meta

    • Log in
    • Entries feed
    • Comments feed
    • WordPress.org



  • Home
  • Mixtapes
    • Metal Mixtapes
    • Minor Key Mixtapes
    • Christmas Mixtapes
  • Mini Movie Reviews
    • Recent Reviews
    • Full List (A – Z)
  • Board Game Reviews
    • Recent Reviews
    • Children’s Game Reviews
    • Expansion Reviews
    • Full List (A-Z)
  • Reader Mail
  • About
  • Contact
© Copyright www.isleyunruh.com